Two highly anticipated CMS releases, Drupal 7.x and WordPress 3.x, are both set to appear in the next month or two. Drupal 7 is currently in Alpha release, but is aiming for a Beta release later this month. WordPress is a little bit ahead, having published a Release Candidate on May 28th. In light of the coincidental (?) timing of these two major releases, let's take a look at some of the new features in each release, and see which is more exciting for its respective community.
Drupal 7 - What's New

For nearly two years, the number one stated objective for Drupal 7 has been improved usability. One of the most common complaints from Drupal detractors has always been that Drupal can be difficult for site administrators to use. Drupal 7 includes a number of usability improvements to help combat this perception. Using the administrative back-end has been made simpler in three main ways: better organized admin menus, making it easier to find the correct task; easier-to-use edit content functionality, with better support of WYSIWYGs; and customizable admin dashboards to provide shortcuts to common tasks for admin users.
Besides these niceties, Drupal 7 also includes the performance and security improvements that one would expect of any major release. In addition, a number of popular modules, most notably CCK, have been added to Drupal core, making the standard Drupal installation a more complete, ready-to-use package. There will also be a second installation profile, Minimal, included that will only contain a few very basic modules, if you want more control over which modules are installed on your site.
And speaking of installing modules...Drupal 7 will also feature an interface to download and install modules with a couple clicks - FTP is no longer necessary. Many less advanced Drupal users will surely appreciate this simpler installation process.
WordPress 3 - What's New?

First off, WordPress MU (Multi-User) will be included as a core piece of WordPress 3, making it possible to manage multiple websites through one dashboard. It will also make it much easier to install and use BuddyPress, a popular suite of social functionality that requires MU as its base. Another big feature is Custom Post Types. Up until now, WordPress has allowed for two content types out of the box: Posts and Pages. In WP 3, you can create your own custom content types, such as team member, customer testimonial, or portfolio item. This important addition will force many people to recognize WordPress as a "true" CMS, if they haven't already.
Another new feature of this release is a (much) better system for creating and editing navigation menus. Also, it will be possible to create custom taxonomies in WordPress 3. Taxonomies were previously limited to the default two: Categories and Tags. The addition of Custom Post Types and Taxonomies are two more steps towards making WordPress look like much more than "just" a blogging platform.
———
So which platform wins? In terms of which release is the more exciting, it is hard to ignore the big new features in WordPress 3. This expanded feature set promises to move WordPress into a whole new category of software, and create competition for other, larger platforms. However, the new features in Drupal 7 are still very exciting to anyone in the Drupal community.
In terms of comparing the two platforms to each other, WordPress still has a ways to go. Though it may be perfect for smaller applications, Drupal still wins in terms of security, power, and flexibility. Dries Buytaert assessed the situation well with a couple of retweets from his Twitter account:
Dries: RT @chx1975: WordPress is now approximately where Drupal was around Drupal 5 w/ content types. See you in 2015.
Dries: Agreed, and fair enough. RT @newoceans_en: @Dries Drupal 7 will hopefully be where WordPress was around 5 years ago regarding UX.
It is very clear from the promises of these two new releases at least that Drupal is attempting to become more user-friendly (WordPress' strength), and WordPress is reaching for some of Drupal's strengths, such as custom content types and taxonomies. Both platforms appear poised to become very powerful tools in the world of Web development.



nice comparison! frank
nice comparison!
frank
The CMS Tug of War
It's nice to see a fairly current comparison on this since the new releases are here. You migh want to check out this other recent review, with a very different slant on the comparisons... <a href=http://www.dss-int.com/articles/2010/10/15/the-cms-tug-of-war-wordpress-vs-drupal-vs-joomla/ title="CMS Tug of War">
The PHP syntax "=="
I think the *PHP syntax* "$drupal == $wordpress" is pretty accurate - both are (now) very flexible & very usable out of the box, both have a lot of the same features. That said, they are clearly not identical and take very different approaches to reach similar goals.
Damien
Just to clarify
The big new features of Wordpress:
* Multi-user: Drupal has done multisite installations for a really long time
* Custom Post Types: In drupal this is a standard feature, i think wordpress has added some custom fields which is called CCK in drupal 6. CCK has also been around for ages and in drupal 7 has been moved into core and has a whole new api.
* Taxonomies: Again this is old old news for drupal users
So i think this line "In terms of which release is the more exciting, it is hard to ignore the big new features in WordPress 3"
Is a bit unfair on drupal, since most of those 'big new features' are also included in drupal 7 (and 6, 5...)
A few big new features in drupal:
* CCK moved to core and given own api
* Image handling moved to core, eg drupal can manipulate images (scale, crop, watermark and so on)
* Install modules and themes from within the admin panel (securely ;)
* All new database abstraction layer for easier coding, better performance and better scalability
* Whole new Files api
* Even tighter security (which wordpress lacks)
* even more flexible localisation
* WYSIWYG API moved to core
* etc
Worpress 3 is good, but this drupal 7 release is really amazing
nice
In terms of comparing the two platforms to each other, WordPress still has a ways to go. Though it may be perfect for smaller applications, Drupal still wins in terms of security, power, and flexibility. casino på nätet
I have abandonated Drupal after loosing one month on a project
Yes, one month trying to make a Drupal website multilingual, dedicating more time reading about bugs than working for my deseperated customer. forget it.
The problem with Drupal is that you can fly to the moon.
But you need a special trick to close the door before starting.
We can help!
CommonPlaces can help you out here! Whether through mentoring, or development, just let us know. Shoot us a quick message at commonplaces.com/contact.
Cool!
Great job, you've helped me so much and I am so glad I have chosen your service.
best web host
I'm really enjoying the theme/design of your weblog. Do you ever run into any internet browser compatibility issues? A modest number of my blog audience have complained about my blog not working correctly in Explorer but looks excellent in Firefox. Do you might have any suggestions to help fix this issue?
Contact information
If you could please provide us with an e-mail address or phone number, we'd be happy to speak to you about your needs. Alternatively, feel free to fill out our contact form and we'll have someone get in touch with you.
Thank you,
Emily Murphy
Marketing Coordinator
CommonPlaces e-Solutions
ST
Ease of use and user interface wins hats down.
Who says WP is any less in terms of "security, power, and flexibility"?
I'm not a fanboi on either side, but it'll be good to elaborate on what you mean. Drupal's interface, as much as I have tried to like and understand it, is tedious, geeky, painful.
I've had custom content types since Wordpress 2. The plugin was Custom Fields. WP would be smart to include it in the core functionality, but the functionality is there.
My decision ended at ecommerce. WP-Ecommerce (getshopped.org) and JigoShop are stellar, well supported, simple to use and integrate. Drupal is a painful beast. We had to install the totally different Magento platform which is a whole different beast in itself.
People get comfortable with platforms and languages and interfaces, so it's fully understandable that there is loyalty on either "side".
But to a new user starting out, I'd recommend Wordpress hands down.
Post new comment