4 min read

Firms Risk Litigation for ADA Website Non-Compliance


Government regulation has caught up with technology; businesses that were first impacted in their physical space by ADA Title III accessibility regulations will be some of the first ones faced with similar online accessibility concerns now. Those not in compliance may be risking litigation. Here’s what you need to know about the why’s and how’s of ADA compliance.

History of ADA

In 1990, Congress passed the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), prohibiting discrimination against people with disabilities. Disability can be defined as a mental or physical impairment that limits major life activities. The Act covered a variety of areas regarding employment, transportation, communication, and public access. Title III of the act prohibited discrimination on the basis of disability in places of public accommodation, or as the ADA defines it, “businesses that are generally open to the public and that fall into one of 12 categories listed in the ADA, such as restaurants, movie theaters, schools, daycare facilities, recreation facilities, and doctors' offices” as well as commercial facilities.

After the ruling, businesses complied, removing physical barriers that limited accessibility for disabled individuals. Government agencies and businesses added street curb-cuts, enhanced crosswalk signals with audio cues, built wheelchair-accessible ramps and added braille and other enabling features to public spaces and physical buildings. The focus was on removing physical barriers. Little, if any, attention was paid to the virtual/digital space such as websites.  

In 2010, the Department of Justice (DOJ), the enforcement body for the ADA, released an Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPR) regarding disabilities and the online world. They acknowledged the public’s increasing use of and reliance on the Internet as a way to interact with and gather information on businesses and organizations. Because of this growing dependency on the web, the DOJ intended to add website accessibility as part of their interpretation of the ADA.

Rulemaking and Litigation

In our previous blog post about ADA compliance, we mentioned that there is not an explicit list of requirements to be ADA compliant as the rules are constantly changing with different legislation. However, the World Wide Web Consortium’s (W3C) WCAG2.0 Level AA details are a good place to start.

The years-long delay in final ruling about requirements has opened the door to lawyers eager to cash in on the confusion surrounding ADA regulation interpretations. Encouraged by legal representation, plaintiffs (people unable to access what are considered public accommodation websites) are filing complaints. Interestingly, the NY Post notes that “Federal law bars ADA suits from winning damages — but lawyers are allowed to pursue collection of their legal fees, which can run as high as $25,000, or more…”. With attorneys being the only financial winners of the lawsuits, it puts into question the intent behind the complaint filings.

Whether valid complaints or not, the DOJ is receiving an increasing number of website compliance complaints and is acting on them. According to ADA legal experts Seyfarth Shaw, ADA Title III lawsuits continue to rise. In some instances, companies are starting to lose judgments and are being forced to make website updates according to vague regulations. In June 2017, Forbes reported that Florida-based grocery food chain Winn-Dixie lost the first-of-its-kind trial for ADA compliance. The courts ruled that Winn-Dixie must update their website to accommodate blind online customers and pay $100,000 to the plaintiff’s attorneys in legal fees. Winn-Dixie is appealing. A similar lawsuit is underway in California against Hobby Lobby.

What Can You Do to Make Your Website ADA Compliant?

Section 508 of the Workforce Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (amended 1998). 

Federal agencies have been subject to disability compliance for some time. They abide by Section 508. Although not identical to the expected ADA compliance regulations, it offers an ideal starting point. Becoming familiar with W3C’s WCAG2.0 Level AA guidelines will also put you well on the path to compliance.

The more you know, the better prepared you’ll be to adapt to upcoming regulation mandates. At the very least, companies should arm themselves with basic tools to deter litigation attempts and limit liability.

The minimum. 

At a bare minimum, websites not already subject to compliance should provide alternative ways of interacting with the companies they represent. Be sure to include a phone number so patrons can call and get information or interact with a live person. Add a statement informing visitors that you’re moving toward compliance and invite input via an online form; then work on implementing those concerns first.

Preparing for screen readers. 

The American Foundation for the Blind recommends screen reading software to its members. According to them, “[s]creen readers are software programs that allow blind or visually impaired users to read the text that is displayed on the computer screen with a speech synthesizer or braille display.” For website owners/managers, adding more detailed HTML programming language to a website allows screen reading software to better perform or ‘read’ the site.

SEO - more than just search results. 

The better search engine optimization you have on your website, the more ADA-friendly it is. Be sure to include image alt tags so photos and graphics have a text description, add meta page descriptions to help orient visitors, provide full-text transcripts for all pre-recorded audio, and include appropriately identified column and row headers on data tables. Be wary of keyword stuffing though. Writing alt tags with a human reader in mind is better to practice than writing expressly for internet web spiders in search of key phrases. Our SEO checklist is a great tool if you aren’t sure where to start.

Compliance Coding and the Human Touch

The good news is that over the years, web development (and CMS) platforms have been addressing compliance issues and including appropriate coding as part of their structure. Some web platforms are more predisposed to ADA compliance than others. Drupal, for instance, has long considered compliance important, including features like screen reader coding and SEO prompts in its version 7 launch in 2011. Drupal Version 8, released in 2015 adds aural alerts, more semantic HTML5 elements among other features to more fully extend accessibility. By design, Drupal has long been a natural fit when considering a website update, but others are catching up. With the upcoming change to Version 9, Drupal is again dedicated to developing compliant sites that meet WCAG 2.0 and ATAG 2.0 regulations. In 2016, WordPress was made more accessible when it announced that it would be conforming to the WCAG 2.0 level AA guidelines. HubSpot also publishes compliance information to their customers that help guide their customers on the topic.

Coding alone cannot guarantee success, but it’s a great start. Human interpretation of compliance standards is still necessary to ensure content is perceivable, operable, understandable, and robust. Someone has to create the code, format content, build the features and then interact with it to be sure accessibility is attained.

Compliance Matters

Having an ADA-compliant website is vital to any organization’s success. Companies that choose to forego compliance run the risk of losing customers and revenue. ADA-compliant websites are a boon to business. They increase potential target audience, contribute revenue to your bottom line and create a great customer experience.

Given the political history of compliance, growing complaints against non-compliant websites, and availability of software platforms that build it into the website coding itself, keeping your website updated may be the best way to meet minimum recommended standards and protect against potential litigation. Not sure where to start? No problem, we're here to help! Contact us today.




Related Posts

3 min read

What Makes a Great Website? 6 Web Design Trends for 2017

Web design trends are ever-changing, evolving and adapting to the latest user behaviors. Each year, marketers learn a little bit more about how to design remarkable, highly functional websites that...
3 min read

Five Reasons Why There is No Replacement for a Website

Today, with the huge popularity of social sites such as Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram, there are some people out there who are wondering if they even need a website. Can't they just set...
3 min read

4 Top Web Trends to Watch Out For in 2018

Year after year, trends in web design and development advance and as technology gets smarter. Staying on top of these updates can be challenging, being ahead of the curve is even harder. Each year,...
5 min read

Design for Drupal 2018, Boston D4D

Beginning in 2009, members of the Drupal community seized on the notion of promoting Drupal design and theming. The leaders of this movement created a group called Design 4 Drupal, or D4D. Fast...